Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jay's avatar

I am grateful for this list Peter--I find here 36 opportunities for welcome self-reflection. Most of these ring immediately true to me (e.g. I feel sorry for the spouse of anyone who does not recognize the wisdom of 2 and 3). Those that I question, I will use this space to briefly organize the rivers of thought they inspire.

4) And sadder.

6) In many ways I have been searching for God everywhere I look, in every song I hear, in every book I read, in every vision of nature's beauty I have seen, for my entire life. I am not looking for a miracle, just something I understand as Divine, as not explicable by the laws of nature, science, and evolution as I understand them. I am still looking, admittedly with the skeptical eyes with which my upbringing and life experiences have trained or cursed me.

7) I agree with this, with the caveat that not all of us have your gift to manifest and mold music. Like Salieri, I can appreciate Mozart's music but cannot hope to create its equal--in my case, not just Mozart's music, but that of any competent musician. Tone deaf, musically inept, I can only listen in wonder and joy. It is both my most sustaining pleasure and my deepest longing.

25) A minor quibble. For many people, weather is a matter of life and death. There definitely is such a thing as bad weather. As a Minnesotan (and a Californian who has just lived through horrific fires fueled by the weather), I think you must know this. The skies may be beautiful but what is wrought within them is not necessarily so.

30) The inverse can also be true. Slavery, discrimination, many forms of inequality that, in a relatively short time, we have banished from liberal culture, were acceptable for thousands of years. Women's rights and LGBTQ+ rights as we know them were unthinkable not long ago, and still are in many cultures. I believe we must always be willing to question and test every one of our traditions against the essential value of simple kindness and, if they don't measure up, discard them.

That's all I've got for now. The other 31 notes I accept without reservation! Be well my friend.

Expand full comment
Elissa Wald's avatar

This inspired me so deeply, Peter. Thank you so much.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...

No posts